Most people buy too much pack. A day hike needs water, food, a warm layer, a rain shell and the small safety stuff you hope never to open, and all of that fits in 20 liters with room to spare. Go much past 26 liters and the pack starts working against you. Half empty, it sags and swings on switchbacks. The spare room also fills up with things you'll carry all day and never touch.
Whether you enjoy the walk comes down to fit, and fit follows your torso rather than your height. Two people the same height can be two pack sizes apart. Measure from the bony bump at the base of your neck down to the top of your hip bones, and buy to that number. At these weights the hip belt is doing more to stop the pack swaying than to carry load, but getting it onto your hip bones instead of your stomach still makes the last two miles a lot better.
The ranking comes from published specs, the design choices each brand made, and what Amazon buyers report after living with these packs. I haven't carried every one of these up a mountain, and I'm not going to pretend I have. The star ratings and review counts are the real numbers off each listing on 2 August 2026. Amazon prices move constantly, so check the current one before you decide.