Chlorine dioxide at a glance
- Kills
- Bacteria, viruses, Giardia
- Cryptosporidium
- Somewhat effective, about 4 hours
- Clear-water wait
- About 15 minutes
- Regulated by
- US EPA pesticide registration
How is chlorine dioxide different from chlorine and iodine?
Chlorine dioxide is a different molecule from the chlorine in bleach or in sodium dichloroisocyanurate tablets, and it behaves differently. It works across a wider pH range and tends to leave less taste behind. It also gets through the tough outer wall of protozoan cysts better than chlorine or iodine does.
That last part is what matters on the trail. The CDC says chlorine and iodine don't work well against parasites, while chlorine dioxide kills Giardia and is somewhat effective against Cryptosporidium.
How long does chlorine dioxide take to work?
Against bacteria and viruses in clear water, about 15 minutes. Against Cryptosporidium, or in cold or cloudy water, up to four hours. Katadyn's Micropur MP1 box prints that four-hour treatment time, and Andrew Skurka cites the same figure for Aquamira's drops. In practice that means a two-bottle rotation: treat one while you drink from the other.
Tablets or two-part drops?
Tablets combine the ingredients in one foil-sealed dose, usually one tablet per liter. Two-part drops keep a chlorine dioxide solution and an acid activator in separate bottles, which you mix for five minutes before adding them to the water.
Drops treat far more water per ounce carried, while tablets are simpler and harder to get wrong. Both are registered with the US EPA under the federal pesticide law, and the registration number on the pack is the one to look up.
What this means when you're choosing
- An EPA registration number printed on the pack
- Cryptosporidium named on the label with a treatment time
- Individually foil-sealed tablets if it will ride in a pack for months
The common mistake
Drinking at fifteen minutes when Crypto is the risk
Fifteen minutes covers bacteria and viruses in clear water. Cryptosporidium needs hours, and cold or silty water slows everything down. The CDC's advice is to filter first and then disinfect, so the filter handles the parasites and the disinfectant covers viruses.
Common questions
Is chlorine dioxide the same as bleach?
No. Household bleach is sodium hypochlorite, which releases chlorine. Chlorine dioxide is a different compound, tastes milder, and is more effective against protozoan cysts.
Can I use chlorine dioxide instead of a filter?
Some ultralight hikers do, and they live with the longer wait. It won't remove sediment, though, so cloudy water still benefits from straining through a cloth or a filter first.
Where this is defined
- Water treatment options when hiking, camping or traveling, US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
- Pesticide product labels, US Environmental Protection Agency