EN/ISO temperature rating at a glance
- Comfort
- Standard woman, sleeping relaxed
- Limit
- Standard man, curled up
- Extreme
- Survival only, ignore it
- Typical gap
- About 10 to 15 F
What the standard replaced
Before the standard existed, a bag's rating was whatever the brand felt like printing. EN 13537, since updated as ISO 23537, replaced that with a heated mannequin in a climate chamber and a defined method, which is why ratings are broadly trustworthy now.
Comfort, limit and extreme
The test produces three numbers people care about. Comfort is the temperature at which a standard adult woman sleeps comfortably. Limit is where a standard adult man sleeps curled up but not shivering. Extreme is a survival figure for six hours without hypothermia, and it should be ignored entirely when shopping, because it describes surviving a night rather than sleeping through one.
Why the number on the label is usually the limit
Here's the catch. Most bags are named after the limit number, so a bag sold as a 20 degree bag typically has a comfort rating closer to 30. If you sleep cold, buy on the comfort number, and expect the bag on the shelf labelled for your conditions to be roughly ten degrees optimistic for you.
What the test actually does
A heated mannequin dressed in a base layer and lying on a standardised pad inside the bag, in a climate chamber. The heaters hold it at a fixed skin temperature and the machine measures how much power that takes at various air temperatures, from which the ratings are derived.
That is why the numbers are comparable at all, and also why they read as abstract. A mannequin does not sleep badly, does not have a bad hydration day, and never crawls into the bag already cold.
Why your experience differs from the number
The test assumes a pad doing its job, and a cold pad will make any bag feel ten degrees worse. It assumes a base layer, so sleeping in nothing changes the result. It assumes an adult of standard build, so a small, lean or older sleeper will typically feel colder than the rating implies.
Then there are the things nobody accounts for: going to bed dehydrated, going to bed on a large calorie deficit, a draughty pitch, or a damp bag that has lost some loft. Treat the rating as a laboratory comparison between bags, not a promise about a specific night.
What this means when you're choosing
- Whether the quoted number is comfort or limit, which differ by about 10F
- The comfort figure if you sleep cold, regardless of what the bag is named
- That the rating assumes a pad, a base layer and a tent
The common mistake
Buying on the number in the product name
The name is usually the limit rating. Treating it as the temperature you'll be comfortable at is how people end up wearing every layer they own inside a bag rated for the conditions they're in.
Common questions
Should I buy on the comfort rating or the limit rating?
Comfort, unless you know you sleep warm. The limit figure describes not shivering, which is a lower bar than sleeping well, and it's the one most product names are based on.
Do quilts have EN/ISO ratings?
Mostly not, because the test needs a closed bag around the mannequin and a quilt has no back. Quilt makers publish their own ratings, so compare quilts to quilts and treat a quilt rating as a little more optimistic.
Where this is defined
- ISO 23537-1:2022, requirements for sleeping bags, part 1, International Organization for Standardization
- ISO 23537-1:2022 preview, clause 5.1.1 test principle, iTeh Standards